LANSING, Mich. — A federal appeals court has ruled that Michigan State Police are violating the due process rights of people placed on the state sex offender registry because of convictions from other states, while leaving most of Michigan’s 2021 registry law in place.
The Sixth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals issued its decision Nov. 13 in Doe v. Whitmer, a class action brought by people required to register under the Sex Offenders Registration Act as amended in 2021. The court upheld a lower-court finding that the state police process for deciding whether an out-of-state offense matches a Michigan crime lacks enough procedural safeguards.
The appeals court sided with the state on several other fronts. It agreed that assigning registrants to tiers based on their offense, rather than an individual risk review, is rationally tied to the goal of reducing repeat offenses, and it upheld limits on when registrants can petition to come off the list. It also rejected claims that rules requiring people to report school, job and vehicle information are unconstitutionally vague.
On the biggest issue, whether the law can be applied to older offenses, the court sent the claims back to the federal district court that first heard the case. Most of the plaintiffs committed their crimes before 2011 and saw their registration terms stretched, often to life. The trial judge must now decide whether those claims are moot after a Michigan Supreme Court ruling earlier this year.
That state decision, issued Sept. 9 in People v. Smith, held that the 2021 law amounts to unconstitutional retroactive punishment when the offense requiring registration was committed before July 1, 2011. Michigan State Police guidance to officers says anyone registered solely for such an older Michigan offense is being permanently removed from the registry and has no further duty to register or report.
The 2021 version of the law took effect March 24, 2021. One judge on the three-judge panel dissented on the out-of-state issue and would have sent it back for more review.
Section: More Lansing MI crime news
Filed under: Lansing MI Crime News